← Back to Elementary
Elementary Season 2
Season Analysis

Elementary

Season 2 Analysis

Season Woke Score
4
out of 10

Season Overview

No specific overview for this season.

Season Review

Season 2 of the series continues to develop the modern-day partnership between Sherlock Holmes and Joan Watson in New York City. The narrative follows a procedural format, emphasizing complex criminal investigations and the intellectual growth of the protagonists. This season introduces Mycroft Holmes, exploring the fractured family dynamics and secret pasts of the Holmes brothers. Joan Watson transitions from a subordinate apprentice to an independent detective, eventually seeking her own residence to establish a life separate from Sherlock. The show focuses heavily on character development and logic-driven puzzles, often using contemporary issues like drone technology and cyber-activism as backdrops for its mysteries.

Categorical Breakdown

Identity Politics5/10

The series is built on the race and gender-swapping of Dr. Watson and Jamie Moriarty. It utilizes a diverse cast in leadership roles within the NYPD and British intelligence, though it generally avoids explicit lectures on systemic oppression or white privilege.

Oikophobia2/10

The narrative maintains a high degree of respect for law enforcement and civil institutions. While the show features corrupt individual officials, the legal systems of the United States and United Kingdom are portrayed as essential to maintaining order and justice.

Feminism6/10

Joan Watson is a career-focused woman who rejects traditional domesticity in favor of professional excellence. The show centers on her transition to an equal partner who demands independence, while also reimagining the series' primary antagonist as a brilliant female mastermind.

LGBTQ+3/10

A transgender character, Ms. Hudson, appears as an intelligent scholar and friend of the leads. The show presents her identity as a normalized fact of her life, avoiding heavy-handed ideological messaging while ensuring her status as a capable professional.

Anti-Theism3/10

Sherlock Holmes embodies a strictly rationalist and secular worldview. He views logic and empirical evidence as the only valid paths to truth, treating religious belief as a human quirk rather than a source of moral authority or objective reality.